California Gov. Gavin Newsom has spent years expanding benefits for illegal immigrants. A new City Journal investigation shows his wine businesses may also benefit from their labor. The company running field operations at Newsom’s Oso Vineyard in Napa County has a record of employing workers with complicated immigration status, including a former employee’s claim that roughly 80 percent of crews were unauthorized and that management knew.
The PlumpJack Collection of Wineries, which Newsom founded in 1995, bought the 129-acre Oso Vineyard in Pope Valley in 2022 for $14.5 million. PlumpJack now owns more than 400 acres of vineyards in Napa County. Newsom placed his interests in a blind trust in 2019 and says he has no operational involvement; the Oso purchase and RVM contract occurred after the trust was established. Tax returns show he and his wife made at least $11 million from 2019 through 2024, most of it from wineries, restaurants, and other investments.
PlumpJack contracts Renteria Vineyard Management (RVM) to run the vineyard. A PlumpJack website calls owner Oscar Renteria Oso’s “long-time vineyard manager.”
A former RVM worker, who said he has lived in the U.S. illegally for more than a decade, told the reporters, “About 80 percent of all of us who worked there [were in the country illegally].” Asked whether management knew, he said, “Absolutely, of course. There was a lot of them.” Industry sources describe high rates of unauthorized labor as common across California vineyards. Renteria himself has hinted at it for years. In 2017 he told the American Immigration Council, “Many of our farm workers have what I call a complicated immigration status.”
Federal H-2A guest-worker filings listed Oso as a worksite in 2022 and 2023, then stopped. The reporters found no H-2A application naming RVM or PlumpJack as the employer. RVM doesn’t appear in the federal E-Verify database either (E-Verify is voluntary for most private employers).
In 2022, the Labor Department found wage-and-hour violations involving 45 RVM workers, with $6,810 in back wages and $23,018 in penalties. City Journal also tested it: a contact called RVM posing as a newly arrived Mexican national with no green card and no Social Security number. The employee took his number and said a manager would follow up. “That means they’re going to hire him,” another illegal immigrant source told the reporters.
Taxpayers help fund Napa farmworker housing. Napa County runs three taxpayer-supported farmworker housing complexes with subsidized rooms, health care, English classes, and legal services, and the reporters confirmed illegal immigrants live there. The program, which began in the early 2000’s and is mostly grower- and resident-funded, received $250,000 a year in state matching funds under a 2017 law; Newsom’s 2026 bill raised the state match to as much as $500,000 a year.
Newsom also vetoed A.B. 1136, a bill that would have required unpaid leave for immigration proceedings and longer reinstatement rights for detained workers. Farm labor contractors warned it could create “constructive knowledge” of unauthorized status and thus federal liability; Newsom’s veto cited existing protections, an unreasonable 12-month window, and implementation costs exceeding $10 million. Oscar Renteria donated to Newsom’s first campaign for governor.
Newsom’s office says he’s walled off. Spokesman Izzy Gardon said the governor “placed his business interests in a blind trust when he took office in 2019” and “has no involvement in PlumpJack’s operations or management.” PlumpJack said it expects “all vendors working with [it] to comply with the law.” RVM didn’t respond.
A blind trust separates operational control but does not eliminate the economic benefit. The man who wants to be the Democrats’ 2028 nominee sells high-end Napa Cabernet while California taxpayers help subsidize housing for the agricultural workforce, including crews picking grapes in an industry where he still holds a stake.





