Entering his final two months as California’s governor, Gavin Newsom is considering commuting prisoners’ death sentences to life without parole.
Newsom, a Democrat who styles himself as a liberal Catholic, engaged in some navel-gazing on his podcast regarding the subject, saying, “I have to prepare for my own consciousness, my rocking chair test.” Early in his first term, Newsom ended executions in California, a moratorium that would no doubt remain in place with the likely next Democratic governor, Xavier Bacerra.
California voters previously rejected a state proposition in 2016 that would have ended the death sentence for those convicted of first-degree murder. It has historically been one of the issues the state’s voters take a more conservative view of than the entrenched one-party Democratic political class, though it is unclear how such a proposition would fare a decade later.
State Democratic Assemblyman Nick Schultz, the chair of the chamber’s public safety committee, encouraged Newsom to follow through with commuting the death sentences, claiming, “He’s sitting in a very unique position today to do something that takes incredible political courage and vision.” Liberals have criticized the death penalty for years based on a specious arguments surrounding its supposed immorality and lack of deterrent effect, ignoring the fact that certain crimes deserve the ultimate punishment. How this is a courageous position, rather than a tendentious do-gooder view, is left unexplained.
While liberal Catholics may align with Newsom’s view on the immorality of the death penalty, the Catholic Church historically approved of the practice, before shifting its view in modern times. In any case, Newsom and aligned Catholic Democrats’ insistence that the issue is a matter of deep moral conviction rings hollow given that they embrace secular liberal views on abortion, and reject church teaching on a host of other social issues.
Given Newsom’s barely hidden plans to run for President in 2028, his decision on the commutations has again sparked talk of whether he will damage his nomination chances. In actuality, though, commuting death row inmates’ sentences would merely confirm Newsom’s limousine liberal reputation across the country, while not being enough to win over his party’s leftist fringe.



