A sweeping visa revocation effort now underway could upend the asylum claims of hundreds of thousands of foreign nationals who entered the country as tourists or business travelers.
The State Department plans to revoke as many as 200,000 nonimmigrant B1 and B2 visas issued between 2016 and 2026 to foreign nationals who later filed for asylum, according to a report by Andrew Arthur, resident fellow in law and policy at the Center for Immigration Studies. Arthur's analysis, building on original coverage from the Washington Post, lays out the legal machinery behind the plan and its likely consequences.
Federal immigration law separates visas into two tracks. Section 222(a) governs immigrant visas for those seeking permanent residency, while section 222(c) covers nonimmigrant visas for temporary visitors under categories defined in section 101(a)(15) of the Immigration and Nationality Act. As the nonpartisan Congressional Research Service explains, "an individual who applies for either type of visa may be issued or refused the visa before entering the United States. Securing either type of visa serves as evidence of permission to travel to the United States but without a guarantee of admission at a U.S. port of entry," according to CRS.
B1/B2 visas are typically issued jointly and remain valid for multiple brief visits across a full decade, which explains why the revocations reach back nearly ten years. Section 221(i) of the INA authorizes the State Department to revoke any visa "at any time" and requires notifying the Department of Homeland Security immediately afterward. For those already inside the country, revocation triggers removability under section 237(a)(1)(B) of the INA.
Arthur notes the effort appears narrowly aimed at people who entered on B1/B2 visas, filed affirmative asylum applications directly with U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services, and are still awaiting a decision from an asylum officer. USCIS data cited in the CIS piece shows that historically, "about 79 percent of affirmative asylum applicants self reported the status in which they entered the United States before applying for asylum. Of those who provided a response, 32 percent reported having entered on B2 visas (tourists) and 5.8 percent reported having entered on B1 visas (temporary business visitors)."
Given that USCIS currently has more than 1.4 million pending affirmative applications, Arthur calculates that upward of 418,000 of those cases likely involve people who entered lawfully on business or tourist visas.
The legal issue at the heart of the matter is what's called non-immigrant intent. Applicants must convince consular and border officers they maintain a foreign residence they don't intend to abandon. Anyone who secretly planned to seek asylum upon arrival would have misrepresented that intent, a misrepresentation Arthur says amounts to lying to a federal officer, a crime under multiple federal statutes and a serious credibility problem in later asylum proceedings.
Congress addressed exactly this scenario in 2005, amending the INA so adjudicators may weigh "the consistency between the applicant's or witness's written and oral statements... and any inaccuracies or falsehoods in such statements, without regard to whether an inconsistency, inaccuracy, or falsehood goes to the heart of the applicant's claim."
Arthur also flags a July interim rule allowing asylum officers to refer applications to immigration judges without an interview when an applicant doesn't merit a discretionary grant, a mechanism he suggests could pair naturally with the new revocations. He cites the Board of Immigration Appeals' recent decision in Matter of P-A-C-, which held that fraudulent conduct falling short of an outright asylum bar still counts as a valid negative discretionary factor.
As Arthur puts it, "DOS's actions are overdue, because if more than 400,000 aliens applied for and received temporary visas by lying about the fact they never intended to go home, it's a glaring failure and an abuse of our laws."
Revoking fraudulently obtained visas is a necessary first step toward restoring integrity to a system that has been exploited for decades, but it cannot be the last one. Real border security demands that Washington pair this enforcement action with far tougher restrictions on both legal and illegal immigration, closing every loophole that has allowed millions to game the system and prioritizing the interests of American citizens above all else.
Subtitle: Fraud allegations could reshape asylum backlog nationwide
By: Jose Nino
Body: A sweeping visa revocation effort now underway could upend the asylum claims of hundreds of thousands of foreign nationals who entered the country as tourists or business travelers.
The State Department plans to revoke as many as 200,000 nonimmigrant B1 and B2 visas issued between 2016 and 2026 to foreign nationals who later filed for asylum, according to a report by Andrew Arthur, resident fellow in law and policy at the Center for Immigration Studies. Arthur's analysis, building on original coverage from the Washington Post, lays out the legal machinery behind the plan and its likely consequences.
Federal immigration law separates visas into two tracks. Section 222(a) governs immigrant visas for those seeking permanent residency, while section 222(c) covers nonimmigrant visas for temporary visitors under categories defined in section 101(a)(15) of the Immigration and Nationality Act. As the nonpartisan Congressional Research Service explains, "an individual who applies for either type of visa may be issued or refused the visa before entering the United States. Securing either type of visa serves as evidence of permission to travel to the United States but without a guarantee of admission at a U.S. port of entry," according to CRS.
B1/B2 visas are typically issued jointly and remain valid for multiple brief visits across a full decade, which explains why the revocations reach back nearly ten years. Section 221(i) of the INA authorizes the State Department to revoke any visa "at any time" and requires notifying the Department of Homeland Security immediately afterward. For those already inside the country, revocation triggers removability under section 237(a)(1)(B) of the INA.
Arthur notes the effort appears narrowly aimed at people who entered on B1/B2 visas, filed affirmative asylum applications directly with U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services, and are still awaiting a decision from an asylum officer. USCIS data cited in the CIS piece shows that historically, "about 79 percent of affirmative asylum applicants self reported the status in which they entered the United States before applying for asylum. Of those who provided a response, 32 percent reported having entered on B2 visas (tourists) and 5.8 percent reported having entered on B1 visas (temporary business visitors)."
Given that USCIS currently has more than 1.4 million pending affirmative applications, Arthur calculates that upward of 418,000 of those cases likely involve people who entered lawfully on business or tourist visas.
The legal issue at the heart of the matter is what's called non-immigrant intent. Applicants must convince consular and border officers they maintain a foreign residence they don't intend to abandon. Anyone who secretly planned to seek asylum upon arrival would have misrepresented that intent, a misrepresentation Arthur says amounts to lying to a federal officer, a crime under multiple federal statutes and a serious credibility problem in later asylum proceedings.
Congress addressed exactly this scenario in 2005, amending the INA so adjudicators may weigh "the consistency between the applicant's or witness's written and oral statements... and any inaccuracies or falsehoods in such statements, without regard to whether an inconsistency, inaccuracy, or falsehood goes to the heart of the applicant's claim."
Arthur also flags a July interim rule allowing asylum officers to refer applications to immigration judges without an interview when an applicant doesn't merit a discretionary grant, a mechanism he suggests could pair naturally with the new revocations. He cites the Board of Immigration Appeals' recent decision in Matter of P-A-C-, which held that fraudulent conduct falling short of an outright asylum bar still counts as a valid negative discretionary factor.
As Arthur puts it, "DOS's actions are overdue, because if more than 400,000 aliens applied for and received temporary visas by lying about the fact they never intended to go home, it's a glaring failure and an abuse of our laws."
Revoking fraudulently obtained visas is a necessary first step toward restoring integrity to a system that has been exploited for decades, but it cannot be the last one. Real border security demands that Washington pair this enforcement action with far tougher restrictions on both legal and illegal immigration, closing every loophole that has allowed millions to game the system and prioritizing the interests of American citizens above all else.





