The Supreme Court has blocked the Trump administration’s new rules that banned gender reassignment for federal prisoners and mandated that they be housed according to their biological sex.
The ruling comes after the Department of Justice (DOJ) filed an emergency request to enforce the administration’s policy, after a lower court struck it down. Justices Clarence Thomas and Samuel Alito were the only members of the Court who dissented.
While the administration’s executive order allows for psychiatric treatment to be provided to prisoners claiming they are the opposite sex, it ended the provision of any medical or surgical sex-change treatments, and ensured that “males are not detained in women’s prisons.” It also rejected the Left’s Orwellian framing of sex-change operations as “gender affirming,” as well as the idea that any socially-constructed genders exist beyond the reality of male and female.
The Court’s ruling departs from its typical decisions on broader transgender issues in recent years. Court majorities have previously sided with Trump administration policies restricting transgender people from serving in the military, as well as mandating that an individual’s biological sex be listed on their passport. The Court also previously upheld Tennessee’s ban on sex-change procedures for minors, support of which has become a litmus test for the Democratic Party.
Attorneys for the transgender inmates involved in the case argued that ending hormone therapy for those currently receiving it would lead to adverse physical and mental health effects. Their argument focused on the implications of discontinuing current treatment, rather than the policy as a whole or the effects of allowing male-to-female prisoners to be housed with women.
The DOJ has appealed the lower court’s original ruling to the D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals, and the Supreme Court will be able to review the case again if the appeal is rejected. Since no justice commented on their reasons for rejecting the emergency request, it is unclear what their specific thinking on the matter is.
President Donald J. Trump regularly attacked failed Democratic presidential nominee Kamala Harris on her support for transgender prisoners receiving gender reassignment surgery, which spawned the usual liberal apologetics spinning her position was supposedly more nuanced. The Democratic Party has regularly made it clear, though, that they regard the issue as a fundamental human right, regardless of how much they struggle to explain it to voters.



